Frozen Pizzas Compared

Advertisement

Compare frozen pizzas from Coles, Dr. Oetker, McCain and Woolworths on factors including value for money, variety, taste & quality of ingredients, ease of preparing and overall customer satisfaction.

See Our Ratings Methodology

Most Satisfied Customers | Dr. Oetker

In Canstar Blue’s first customer satisfaction ratings for frozen pizzas, Dr. Oetker has claimed the top spot, with five stars for variety, taste & quality of ingredients, ease of preparing and overall satisfaction.

Dr. Oetker a slice ahead in frozen pizza ratings

Frozen pizza is often an underrated addition to the shopping list, with the tasty option it’s a handy meal for households that are rushed off their feet, or those who aren’t confident in their culinary abilities. With the versatility to feed a small army, frozen pizzas are also generally cheaper than most takeaway pizzas, making them easier on the budget as well.

While they may not be the go-to option for those looking to make good on their New Year’s resolution, having a pizza in the freezer in case of ‘emergencies’ can give households peace of mind after a long day at work. And when it comes to choosing the pizza to stock up on, consumers aren’t short of options and flavours. But where can you find the best quality and value? That’s where Canstar Blue comes into play.

We’ve surveyed almost 500 Australian adults to find out which brand is the best-rated in Australia. The four brands included in our 2019 review were rated in the following order for overall satisfaction:

  • 1st Dr. Oetker
  • 2nd McCain
  • 3rd Woolworths
  • 4th Coles

In our inaugural ratings for frozen pizza, three of the four brands scored a five-star result in at least one category, but Dr. Oetker was a clear winner overall, and when it comes to taste & ingredients.

Get a pizza this

Frozen pizzas are a popular option for many households, with almost two in five (38%) respondents to our survey eating frozen pizzas at least once a week, with 3% of those even eating it daily! While 76% of respondents enjoy cooking their own meals, over half (51%) eat frozen pizzas simply because they don’t have enough time to cook.

18-29-year-olds are more likely to buy the cheapest pizza available, or whichever brand is on special. But taste was found to be the biggest deciding factor for most, with over half of shoppers (56%) basing their decision on their taste buds, with a third (35%) letting their wallet do the choosing. Our survey identified the following insights:

Best-Rated Frozen Pizzas

Dr. Oetker

A German brand, Dr. Oetker has been operating for over 100 years, covering all ranges of food, including cake mixes, yoghurts, and frozen pizzas. Dr. Oetker’s pizzas range primarily centres around the thin and crispy Ristorante-styled pizza, which includes flavours such as Hawaiian, Speciale, Quattro Formaggi and Peperoni. Each pizza is between 310g and 390g, all costing $7.50 at the checkout.

  • With five stars for variety, taste & quality of ingredients, ease of preparing and overall customer satisfaction, value for money was the only category where Dr. Oetker scored four stars.

McCain

A Canadian company, McCain has long been a favourite for Australian households, with the catchphrase ‘Ah McCain, you’ve done it again’ a common saying in the early 2000s. Offering anything and everything within the frozen food section of your local supermarket, McCain’s frozen pizza range includes plenty of options for the busy household. With Family Pizzas, Ultra-Thin Pizzas, Takeaway Pizzas, Rustica, Pockets, Slices, Singles and even Pizza Bases, McCain does it all. Family Pizzas (500g) will cost you $6.50, while the Rustica range will cost you $7.50 and the Ultra-Thin range will scan through for $7 at the checkout.

  • With a five-star rating on variety, McCain got four stars for taste & quality of ingredients, ease of preparing and overall satisfaction, while scoring three stars for value for money.

Woolworths

As with most grocery lines, Woolworths offers Aussies its own range of frozen pizzas, including flavours such as Hawaiian, BBQ Meat Lovers, Pepperoni, BBQ Chicken, and Four Cheeses, with the pizzas ranging in size from 360g up to 500g. The Hawaiian and BBQ Meat Lovers will set you back just under $3 at the checkout, while the rest of the Woolworths range will cost you $4, although in comparison to the other brands available on the shelves, Woolworths is certainly a cheaper option.

  • The only brand to get a five-star rating on value for money, Woolworths scored four stars in all other categories, including taste, variety, ease of preparing and overall satisfaction.

Coles

Coles-Pizza

Not to be outdone by Woolworths, Coles also has its own range of frozen pizzas, each available from $3. Flavours include classics such as Hawaiian, BBQ Meat Lovers, Supreme, Margherita, and Pepperoni, with Pizza Subs also available in Meatball and Cheese & Tomato flavours. Each pizza weighs in between 470g and 500g, with the Subs costing $4.50 per 250g-270g pack.

  • Rounding out the results, Coles was rated three stars in all categories, including taste & quality of ingredients, ease of preparing and overall satisfaction.

Which frozen pizza should I buy?

While frozen pizza may not be the first thing you think of when you do the grocery shopping, there’s no doubting it can be a lifesaver when it comes to getting dinner on the table in a hurry. There’s certainly a convenience factor when it comes to frozen pizza. But which brand and flavour you end up putting in your trolley will come down to your personal preferences, as some prefer the cheap and cheerful pizza and garlic bread combo from the supermarket chains, while others may prefer a bit more substance to their pizzas, and are happy to fork out a bit of extra cash for a larger meal.

Online Grocery Shopping Reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

Canstar Blue surveyed 3,000 Australian adults across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have purchased and eaten a pre-made frozen meal (i.e. from the frozen section of the supermarket) in the last 6 months – in this case, 474 people.

Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then alphabetically. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.

Advertisement