Ice Cream Tubs


Compare ice cream tubs from Golden North, ALDI Monarc Indulge, Peters, Bulla, Connoisseur, Ben & Jerry’s, Woolworths, Coles, Streets Blue Ribbon and Sara Lee, on taste, value for money, consistency, variety, packaging and overall satisfaction.

See our Ratings Methodology.

Most Satisfied Customers | Golden North

Golden North has scooped Canstar Blue’s award for ice cream tubs for the second year in a row, with five-star reviews from customers on taste, consistency, variety, packaging and overall satisfaction.

Golden North takes two scoops in ice cream tub ratings

On a scorching summer’s day, there’s nothing like a big bowl of ice cream to cool you down! And with non-dairy, gluten-free and nut-free options now widely available, almost everyone can indulge with this special treat. But with so many options to choose from, which ice cream brand serves up the best blend of taste and value? The supermarket freezer aisle is packed full of different brands, so which are worth a try?

Each year, Canstar Blue reveals the answers to these questions. To find out in 2019, we surveyed more than 1,300 consumers who have bought and eaten from a tub of ice cream in the last three months. Ten brands made it into this year’s rating, but it was Golden North who scooped top spot for the second year in a row.

The 10 brands to be featured in our 2019 ice cream tubs review are rated in the following order for overall customer satisfaction:

  • 1st Golden North
  • 2nd ALDI Monarc Indulge
  • 3rd Peters
  • 4th Bulla
  • 5th Connoisseur
  • 6th Ben & Jerry’s
  • 7th Woolworths
  • 8th Coles
  • 9th Streets Blue Ribbon
  • 10th Sara Lee

ALDI Monarc Indulge, Peters, Bulla, Connoisseur, Ben & Jerry’s and Woolworths got four stars for overall satisfaction, while Coles, Blue Ribbon and Sara Lee were left on just three stars apiece. There were some other noteworthy results, including ALDI being the only brand to get five stars on value for money, with Ben & Jerry’s picking up the sole five-star rating for packaging. Ben & Jerry’s additionally topped variety alongside Golden North.

According to our survey, 14% of respondents eat ice cream every day during summer, with 29% stating they eat ice cream straight out of the tub – it’s the only way, some would say! One in four (25%) enjoy the treat on special occasions, while 19% feel guilty about eating it. Just 4% said they prefer to eat single serve ice creams compared to a tub – the more the merrier perhaps.

Australia’s favourite ice cream flavour

When asked what their favourite flavour of ice cream is, vanilla was the most popular choice of survey respondents:

  • Vanilla: 32%
  • Chocolate: 15%
  • Cookies & Cream: 12%
  • Caramel/Salted Caramel: 9%
  • Neapolitan: 9%
  • Mint: 6%
  • Berry (e.g. strawberry, raspberry): 5%
  • Coffee: 5%
  • Fruit flavours (e.g. mango, banana): 3%
  • Other: 6%

So, what is ice cream anyway?

Today is the day you find out you’ve been living a lie! The ice cream you have in your freezer might not actually be ‘ice cream’ at all! According to Food Standards Australia New Zealand, ice cream is officially defined as “a sweet frozen food that is made from cream or milk products or both, and other foods, and is generally aerated”. A food that is sold as ‘ice cream’ must, by law:

  • be ice cream; and
  • contain no less than:
    • 100 g/kg of milk fat; and
    • 168 g/L of food solids.

This means many of the ‘ice cream’ tubs you buy from the supermarket are in fact confectionary due to the lack of dairy cream they contain. Generally speaking, we refer to all products in the freezer aisles as ice cream for the sake of our ratings. You know what we mean…

About the winner – Golden North

Golden North Winner Ice Cream

Golden North is proudly South-Australian made and owned, producing ice cream for almost 100 years. Its products are boasted to be 100% Palm Oil Free, with most of its range also gluten free. The brand’s core ice cream range features vanilla, diet plus vanilla, and cookies & cream. Its ‘Good ‘N Creamy’ line is stated to have a low glycaemic index, and is available in vanilla, wild berries and lemoncello flavours. It also offers a ‘Simply Indulge’ range, which features flavours such as Boysenberry, Café Cino, Chocolate, Honey, Rum & Raisin, Spearmint Sundae, Vanilla and Vanilla Sundae. Tub sizes come in various options including 1L, 1.2L, 2L and 5L, depending on which variety of ice cream you’re after.

Yoghurt Reviews

Frequently asked questions

Canstar Blue surveyed 3,000 Australian adults across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have bought and eaten ice cream from a tub, from a supermarket or grocer (i.e. not from an ice cream store or café/ restaurant) in the last 3 months – in this case, 1,394 people.

Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then by mean overall satisfaction. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.


Latest ice cream articles

Artificial sweeteners linked to risk of obesity and diabetes

Increasing concerns about obesity and sugar consumption have seen many soft drink brands change their ingredients to low or zero calorie sweeteners instead of sugar, but new evidence suggests that some artificial sweeteners may have …

– Read more

Coles recalls vegan chocolate due to presence of milk

Supermarket giant Coles has apologised after admitting that some chocolate blocks marketed to vegans actually contained milk. The New South Wales Food Authority issued a statement stating Coles is conducting a national recall of Coles Sugar …

– Read more

New study reveals six cups of coffee a day may be healthy

If you’ve been thinking about cutting down on your morning coffees, think again. New research has found drinking up to six cups of coffee a day may be healthy for you. The review of 11 major …

– Read more
ice cream calories

The ice cream that could help you lose weight

Want to eat a whole tub of ice cream without the guilt? A new brand has hit the supermarket shelves and fitness fanatics are going crazy for it. Halo Top ice cream was founded by Los …

– Read more

How to lose weight while still eating pasta

No longer do you need to pass by that delicious bowl of spaghetti or carbonara, with a new study claiming that you can lose weight while still enjoying your favourite pasta dish. Conventional wisdom – and …

– Read more