Netflix vs Stan: Head to head comparison

It’s a well-known fact that rivalry breeds success. The Bulls-Pistons rivalry got the Chicago Bulls and Jordan a championship, the space race between Russia and the Unites States got the first man on the moon – you get the picture. And when it comes to streaming here in Australia, it just so happens that we have a rivalry of our own between the US-born Netflix and local hero Stan. When it was revealed back in 2015 that the American streaming titan Netflix would be tossing its hat into the Aussie streaming ring, Stan was gloved up and ready to go, having launched two months prior.

It’s no secret that Netflix is a global streaming sensational. As of April 2020, the service had over 182 million paid subscribers worldwide and a massive catalogue of Netflix Originals to give creatives another avenue to get their masterpieces on the screen. Stan, on the other hand, isn’t operating at such high numbers, but is leading the Aussie-owned SVOD market with over 1.8 million subscribers and a number of its own originals. It may seem like David vs Goliath, but as the demand for streaming increases, the battle between Netflix and Stan remains at an all-time high, with both vying for the attention of the country. But who comes out on top?

Netflix vs Stan

Couple watching TV

As with any side-by-side comparison, you have plenty to look at. There are the stats, content, the price, and then the unmeasurable enjoyment you get from each streaming service, regardless of how good (or bad) your choice in movies is. So, to help settle the argument once and for all, read on to find out which streaming service is the best.

Cost, Free Trials & Cancellation

We’ll start with the basics – just how much will you be dishing out for each service per month. At first glance, it’s clear that both services are pretty much on par with each other. Both charge subscribers at three different membership levels – a Basic plan, Standard plan and Premium plan. As you can see below, the only real difference occurs when you jump up into the Premium bracket, and even then, you can argue ‘what’s a few dollars’ when you’re going for the top shelf?

  • Basic Plan: $10.99 Netflix vs $10 Stan
  • Standard Plan: $16.99 Netflix vs $14 Stan
  • Premium Plan: $22.99 Netflix vs $19 Stan

When it comes to free trials, Stan is the clear winner. It offers 30-day free trials on every plan for all new users, whereby Netflix canned its free trials in March 2020. Both services allow users to cancel whenever they want, with no lock-in contract the order of the day – with your cancellation implemented before the next billing cycle.

  • Winner: While it’s a tight finish, Stan’s slight price difference across all tiers and the free trial allow it to sneak ahead. Stan also inch ahead as Netflix recently announced a price increase to its Standard and Premium plans.

Multiple Devices

Netflix Media

This is a pretty huge factor for a lot of potential subscribers. The more screens and devices that can share an account, the lower the cost is per person. So, if you’re someone who’s planning on cutting the cost between a few of your friends, it may be worth splashing out on a Premium plan from either Netflix or Stan, with both offering screen sharing between four devices at once.

They come out as equals on the Basic plan, with both allowing one device at a time. It’s the Standard and Premium plans that differentiate the two – with Stan’s plan allows for an additional screen in comparison to Netflix across both plans. Even if you’re not looking at it from a cost perspective, having multiple devices and streams going at the same time is just convenient, especially if your household features a lot of different tastes in movies.

  • Winner: Another close finish, but the extra screen available across Stan’s Standard and Premium Plan doing the damage. While potentially not enough to separate the two over the long run, having one additional screen can make a huge difference (and save you fighting over the remote).

Resolution, Data & Watching Offline

Man watching show on phone

As to be expected, quality and resolution go hand-in-hand with how much data you’ll be using on each plan from both services. Netflix and Stan also come up pretty equal in this category. Subscribers will be chewing through around 3GB of data per hour at HD on the Standard plan and 7GB/hour at Ultra HD (also known as 4K) on Premium.

However, it’s surprisingly the Basic plan that sets the two apart – on Stan, you’ll be chewing through 1.3GB/hour, but on Netflix only 700MB. Could a saving of 600MB/hour be enough to set Stan back? Both services also allow downloading for offline playback.

  • Winner: Another tough round, but the possibility of watching two Netflix episodes for the price of one Stan episode on the Basic plan could be the deciding factor for some.

Content Library

Man eating popcorn

Now for the fun stuff. Which streaming service has the better library? Of course, the type of content users chooses to watch is purely subjective, but we’re going to have a crack at it anyway.

Netflix has a much larger content library – coming in with approximately 3,500+ movies and 1,800+ shows available. This is to be expected really, with the streaming giant placing emphasis on Originals (including hits such as Stranger Things and The Irishman) and a larger access to international content, including Spanish-speaking success stories Money Heist and Elite. Netflix has also snagged rights to some spectacular content from alternative sources, such as Black Mirror, Peaky Blinders, The Bodyguard and Riverdale, to name a few.

Stan holds access to slightly less content with approximately 1,300-1,700 movies and 500+ TV shows. But it’s not one to back down without a fight. Stan has secured the rights to some of the most iconic television ever made such as The OC, Grey’s Anatomy and Seinfeld gracing our screens through the “Stan Iconic Series”, with Stan also the home to shows like Better Call Saul, Billions and newcomer Normal People. Stan’s Originals movies category may leave some wanting, but it does look to redeem itself through documentaries and international new releases such as the Academy Award winning movie Parasite.

  • Winner: This is a tough call, and completely dependent on what you look for when you plonk yourself down on the couch for the next few hours.

Should I get Netflix or Stan?

As the final scores are tallied, it becomes clear that not much separates the two besides personal opinion. If you’re a film buff, a fan of re-watching old TV shows, or want to share devices at a low cost, Stan might be your thing. If you’re willing to dish out a little bit more per month for the highest quality and for never-ending Originals, maybe it’s Netflix. To help with the final decision, check out the table below to find out which service may be the best for your next binge session.

  Netflix Basic Plan Stan Basic Plan Netflix Standard Plan Stan Standard Plan Netflix Premium Plan Stan Premium Plan
Free Trial x 30 days x 30 days x 30 days
Monthly Price $10.99 $10 $16.99 $14 $22.99 $19
Resolution SD SD HD HD Ultra HD Ultra HD
Data used/hour 700MB 1.3GB 3GB 2.8GB 7GB 7GB
Simultaneous devices/screens 1 1 2 3 4 5
Offline Capabilities Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Library: TV shows 1,800+ 500+ 1,800+ 500+ 1,800+ 500+
Library: movies 3,500+ 1,300-1,700 3,500+ 1,300-1,700 3,500+ 1,300-1,700
Cancellation Anytime Anytime Anytime Anytime Anytime Anytime

Information from respective websites, accurate as of November, 2021.

While both Stan and Netflix come out swinging, and each have their own strengths, this matchup is too close to call, although we think we’re the real winners here, as there’s no shortage of content to keep us glued to the couch.

Sign up to Disney+

Can’t decide between Netflix and Stan? Why not try Disney+? There are two options to choose from – a monthly subscription at $11.99 per month, or prepay for a year at $119.99 – with both plans including the same features, with unlimited downloads and the ability to stream on up to four screens at the same time.

Brand Subscription Type No. of Screens/same time viewing Advertised Cost^^/month or year
Disney+ Logo

Disney+ Monthly Subscription

  • Stream the Disney+ library, including Disney+ Originals, Star Wars, Pixar, Marvel, National Geographic & Star
  • Watch on 4 screens at the same time
  • Add up to 7 profiles
  • Unlimited downloads of shows and movies on up to 10 devices

min. cost $11.99 over one month

4No. of Screens /same time viewing $11.99
Advertised Cost/month
Get DealCanstar Blue receives a commission for sign-ups through Disney+ *
Disney+ Logo

Disney+ Yearly Subscription

  • Stream the Disney+ library, including Disney+ Originals, Star Wars, Pixar, Marvel, National Geographic & Star
  • Watch on 4 screens at the same time
  • Add up to 7 profiles
  • Unlimited downloads of shows and movies on up to 10 devices
  • Prepay for a yearly subscription and save on the monthly cost

min. cost $119.99 over one year

4No. of Screens /same time viewing $119.99
Advertised Cost/year
Get DealCanstar Blue receives a commission for sign-ups through Disney+ *

Photo credit: bbernard/, Daisy Daisy/, VdZ/

Share this article