Compare female deodorants from Mum, Mitchum, Norsca, Dove, Rexona and Nivea on their effectiveness, smell, value for money, packaging and overall customer satisfaction.
Deodorant probably isn’t the most glamourous item in your bathroom or handbag, but we all know it’s a necessity to help you stay fresh throughout the day. No one enjoys bad BO, especially after a workout or a stressful day at work. But what’s even worse is getting that little black dress stained by deodorant – it’s a lose-lose situation sometimes. With this in mind, there’s certainly a wide range of brands available, so if your current deodorant is letting you down at the most crucial times, we’re here to help!
Canstar Blue has surveyed over 1,000 women to find out which brands keep us gals happy and provide long lasting effectiveness – from the office, to the date night. Brands were put to the test on a range of critical factors, including effectiveness, smell, value for money and packaging as well as overall customer satisfaction. Six brands received the minimum sample size to be included in our ratings, but only one achieved five stars overall – Mum.
The six brands in our 2018 women’s deodorant review have been rated in the following order for overall customer satisfaction:
Mum was rated number one for overall satisfaction as well as for smell of product, value for money and packaging. It also received four stars for effectiveness. Mitchum and Norsca got four stars overall, while Dove, Rexona and Nivea were left with three stars apiece.
Mitchum was the only brand to achieve five stars for effectiveness.
Before we jump into what each brand has to offer, here’s what else our survey revealed:
Aside from revealing the best-rated deodorant brands for women, our research identified the following drivers of customer satisfaction, rated in the following order:
Effectiveness is evidently the biggest factor when buying deodorant and it makes sense – why bother with deodorant if it doesn’t do the job. Smell was the second most important factor, and it’s evident from our ratings that some brands are better than others in this department.
The survey also found that more than half of women (52%) always buy the same brand of deodorant, while 19% buy the cheapest brand.
Deodorants come in all shapes and sizes. The main types you’ll find on supermarket and pharmacy shelves include:
According to our research, almost half of women (48%) purchase roll-on deodorant, while spray came in second with 44%, followed by stick deodorant on 6%. It typically comes down to preference as to which type you buy. It’s important to note that our ratings include feedback on all of these deodorant types.
A third of respondents to our survey (32%) indicated they didn’t know there was a difference between deodorants and antiperspirants, which means some people might be buying the wrong product. While many brands boast 2-in-1 combinations, deodorants and antiperspirants target two separate problems.
It’s a common misconception to think that sweat smells. In actual fact, sweat itself is essentially odourless – it’s the natural bacteria on our skin reacting with sweat that releases the smell we call body odour. So the primary goal of deodorant is to mask the smell of excessive bacteria, while antiperspirants aim to prevent sweating.
The brand Mum was born way back in 1888 and has been rolling its way through the years on a global scale. It offers roll-on (50ml) and spray options (100g), which are all boasted to be 2-in-1 antiperspirant deodorants, plus alcohol free. Fragrances include ‘Cool Pink’ and ‘Dry Active’, stated to be light and delicate to not clash with perfume. While Mum does have fragrances for men, these aren’t sold in Australia.
Throughout Mitchum’s 50+ year history, its main goal has been effectiveness. Mitchum Clinical is available in a variety of fragrances for both women and men, boasting 2-in-1 antiperspirant deodorant with 48-hour protection. It’s claimed to be dermatologist tested and contain aloe and vitamin E to help soothe and condition. The range includes roll-on (50ml), stick (45g), powder (45g) and gel (57g) options.
Available in a range of fragrances for men and women, Norsca antiperspirant deodorants are aimed to combine cool, fresh, exotic and soothing scents to “awaken your senses”. While it does have roll-on options, the women’s range only features three sprays (150g) – clear passion flower, sport and baby powder. Its sport variant is boasted for 48-hour protection with no added alcohol or colourants.
A brand owned by Unilever, Dove says it is committed to helping Aussie women realise their personal beauty. Dove offers roll-on (50ml), stick (45ml) and spray (169ml and 250ml) deodorants, some being a 2-in-1 antiperspirant option. According to Dove, there’s a product to suit every situation, such as ‘Clinical Protection’, boasted to deliver up to 48 hours of protection and ‘Invisible Dry’, claimed to leave no white marks on more than 100 colours. Dove’s antiperspirant deodorants are also created with ¼ moisturising cream.
Another brand owned by Unilever, Rexona provides deodorants for both women and men. Its options include roll-on (50ml), stick (45ml) and spray (250ml). Rexona boasts its invisible Black+White range to protect clothing from stains, while its ‘MotionSense’ technology is said to help with excessive sweating. Fragrances range from apple and pear to light, floral notes. It also features a hypo-allergenic formula with a low scent.
German personal care brand Nivea features a wide range of deodorants – for males and females. Its women’s line-up includes roll-on (50ml) and spray (150ml and 250ml) options. It boasts a number of different formulas from ‘Pearl & Beauty’, stated to feature pearl extracts to support an even skin tone, to ‘Pure Invisible’, which is claimed to protect against white marks on clothes and underarm skin. Nivea also offers its ‘Sensitive Protect’ roll-on deodorant, specifically developed with chamomile extract and avocado oil for sensitive skin, according to Nivea.
In 2018, Nivea got three stars for overall satisfaction, as well as in most other categories. It was four stars on value for money.
customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have purchased and used women’s deodorant from a supermarket or pharmacy (excluding body spray and perfumes) in the last 3 months – in this case, 1,232 people.
Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then by mean overall satisfaction. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.
Body Moisturisers - November 19th
The world of supplements can be a tricky one to navigate, especially as there’s more on offer than just protein. Shelves on shelves are stocked with pre-workouts, post-workouts, BCAAs, pills and all forms of other …– Read more
Body Moisturisers - November 5th
With an increased focus on health and wellbeing over the past few years, the rise of superfoods has been a swift one, with health food stores, supermarkets and cafés jumping on the bandwagon to give …– Read more
Body Wash - October 23rd
You’re looking for a bottle of sunscreen before you leave home with the kids and find one in the depths of a beach bag and wonder: how long has it been since I bought this? …– Read more
Consumer News - October 22nd
Tucking into your meals within a 10-hour window could help you get a good night’s sleep, according to new research. Dr. Satchidananda Panda, a circadian biologist at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in San Diego, …– Read more