Canstar Blue’s 2020 baby carriers review has seen Ergobaby, BABYBJÖRN and Kmart compared on their comfort & support, fit, ease of use, value for money, durability & quality, flexibility, design & style and customer satisfaction.
Ergobaby was rated best for baby carriers for the sixth year in a row, earning five-star reviews in every category and for overall satisfaction in 2020.
Being a parent – especially of newborns – usually means little sleep and tired bodies, so mums and dads naturally appreciate any extra help they can get. And a baby carrier is certainly one way to keep your hands free while keeping a close eye (and tie) between you and your little one.
So, which baby carriers are up to the job? We’ve asked more than 400 parents across Australia about the baby carrier, sling or wrap they bought in the last three years. They rated brands on comfort and support, fit, design, flexibility, ease of use, durability and quality, value for money and overall parent satisfaction. Manufacturers which received the minimum sample size of 30 responses are featured in the report. The idea is to give you as much helpful information as possible about the compared brands, so you can find the right fit for your bub – and budget.
Our latest report shows Ergobaby is still the top baby carrier, since first taking the top spot in our ratings back in 2015. It also dominated this year’s results after it achieved five-star ratings in every category.
Here are the best baby carriers in Australia, as rated by consumers in Canstar Blue’s 2020 review:
Ergobaby holds onto the top spot after receiving the only five-star review for overall satisfaction and most other categories, including comfort & support and durability & quality, while also still rating best everywhere else. BABYBJÖRN steps into second place on four stars, with Kmart rounding up the scores on three stars.
It’s worth mentioning that despite not getting the lead position, BABYBJÖRN still earned five-star ratings for value for money and ease of use. Kmart similarly achieved full marks for value for moeny.
Ergobaby offers a huge range of baby carriers, with most being front carrier-centric. There are several lines available, including Omni 360, Adapt, Cool Air Mesh, Hip Seat, Wrap and Embrace. Prices start from $99 for the Aura Wrap and reach up to $349 for the Omni 360 Cool Air Mesh Baby Carrier.
The Ergobaby Omni 360 Collection is described as the brand’s most versatile range and designed to suit all seating positions. Products are stated to suit babies weighing anywhere between 3.2-20kg, which accommodate babies and small toddlers (up to 36-months old). For a mid-price baby carrier range, most items from the Embrace collection sell for $179. They’re said to contain easy buckling to avoid wrapping or excessive fabric, and are compact enough to roll-up and put in some nappy bags.
BABYBJÖRN is a Swedish company specialising in family and baby products, and has a fairly concise range of baby carriers. The collection tends to lean towards front carriers, although the pricier options can be customised into a front or rear-facing carrier. It’s worth mentioning that the brand’s cheaper models typically stick to basic functionality, but still contain the same materials and designs as the more costly options.
There’s a variety of baby carriers designed to fit the child for at least a year. The Baby Carrier Mini can fit babies who are 12 months old and under, while the Baby Carrier Move can accommodate until the child reaches 15 months. If you’re looking for something that can transition from babies to toddlers, the Baby Carrier One and Baby Carrier One Air are made to sit children up until the age of three. BABYBJÖRN’s baby carriers usually retail between $159.99 and $229.99.
For particularly sporty families, BABYBJÖRN’s Baby Carrier One Air is the brand’s flagship model and is described as being ideal for hiking.
Kmart is a purveyor of affordable and trendy homewares and clothes, but what you might not realise is that it also produces its own baby carrier. Kmart’s 3 Way Baby Carrier is available for $39 and is suitable for babies aged three months and older, with a maximum weight capacity of 15kg.
It offers three carrying positions, including inward-facing, outward-facing (after four months) and back position (after six months). The baby carrier additionally provides adjustable head support for younger infants. Plus, there’s a side pocket on the waistband for extra convenience.
Disney+ has arrived in Australia with all your favourite shows and movies. There are two plan options to choose from – a monthly subscription at $8.99 per month, or prepay for a year at $89.99 and save on the monthly cost. Both plans include the same features, with unlimited downloads and the ability to stream on up to four screens at the same time. This table includes links to a referral partner.
| Brand | Subscription Type | No. of Screens/same time viewing | Advertised Cost^^/month or year | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
min. cost $8.99 over one month |
4 | $8.99 |
Get DealCanstar Blue receives a commission for sign-ups through Disney+ * |
|
min. cost $89.99 over one year |
4 | $89.99 |
Get DealCanstar Blue receives a commission for sign-ups through Disney+ * |
|
^^View important information | |||
Aside from the top three brands that made it into our ratings this year, there are several others you might like to consider:
Hug-a-Bub provides a more affordable collection of slings and wraps compared to many other brands on the market, with all items usually costing between $90 and $120. Expect to see a variety of pocket wraps, lightweight wraps, organic mesh ring slings and reversible sling rings. Hug-a-Bub’s ring sling collection is said to be especially ideal for breastfeeding mums, since these are designed to easily get on & off and work around. All products feature organic cotton and soft-touch fabrics. However, the brand doesn’t offer any traditional carriers.
Baby Tula caters to a large range of ages, selling ergonomic carriers for newborns to toddlers. The different collections include Explore Carriers (3.2-20kg), Free-to-Grow Carriers (3.2-20kg), Half Buckle (3.2-20kg), Standard Carriers (7-20kg) and Toddler Carriers (11-27kg). There are also several mesh carriers. These are all available in a variety of fun colours and prints, each typically retailing around $259 and just under $330. You can also find more online exclusive options through Baby Tula’s website.
Chekoh specialises in wrap carriers and slings, plus mini wraps for your kids to use for their toys. The entire carrier collection includes wrap and sling carriers, swaddles and the brand’s Mini Chekoh wraps. The latest addition to the brand’s baby carrier collection is the Wrap Carrier, which is described as a stretchy one-size-fits-all carrier. Unlike other options on the market, this particular product doesn’t contain any zips, clips, buckles and or velcro. All Chekoh baby carriers retail for $99.95. These are said to be suitable from birth (3kgs) up to 8-10kgs.
Manduca’s range consists of Classic, Pure Cotton and Blackline baby carriers, plus a limited-edition line along with baby slings and accessories. Manduca organic baby carriers are claimed to be ergonomically designed to support both the baby and parent. Sizes are stated to suit infants from 3.5kg, all the way up to 20kg, with most being front-facing carriers. They boast adjustable straps, ergonomically shaped hip belts and integrated head support for comfort and convenience. Typically, prices sit from around $190 and $250, while baby sling carriers are usually available for just under $110.
Did you know Australians spend an average of $114 on a new baby carrier? One in four (25%) find baby carriers more convenient to use than prams and strollers, but not all baby carriers are made equal. Fortunately, a large number of parents are doing their homework and checking online reviews before picking out the best baby carrier for them (38%).
There are a few concerns parents need to think about when it comes to wearing a carrier. A number of people we surveyed said they often get a sore back from using a baby carrier (20%), while 17% worry about their bub falling. It doesn’t help that a similar amount of survey respondents admitted to having previously tried a different baby carrier that didn’t work for them (18%). This all might suggest why two-fifths (44%) of Aussies prefer to have their baby sit at the front, rather than carry them on their back.
Other key findings from our 2020 survey include:
There are two main types – carriers (or ‘pouches’) and backpack carriers. Sling carriers are also popular and worthy of your consideration. One isn’t necessarily better than the other but it does come down to how old your child is and your personal preferences.
The most common type of carriers, these are best-suited for newborns and babies younger than 18 months. They are usually worn off the chest, with the baby facing inwards, but customisable carriers also now allow older children to face outwards.
Of the parents surveyed, 44% reported preference towards having their baby at the front instead of their back. Nearly one in four (20%) reported they often get a sore back from using a baby carrier – no doubt this starts setting in when the little munchkin starts growing up! When your baby starts growing, it may be time to consider a backpack carrier.
Backpack baby carriers often feature rigid frames, but some front-facing carriers are also able to be customised to fit on the back. Those with rigid frames are best-suited to older kids who aren’t exactly babies, but can’t walk long distances yet. If you’ve ever walked a popular hiking trail, there’s probably no doubt you’ve seen these backpack carriers in action.
To the 20% of those surveyed who reported back pain, a backpack carrier might be more suited than a pouch-type. It might also give some relief to parents worried about their baby falling out of the carrier – a pouch evidently lets you keep a better eye on your baby.
Sling types are a variation of the two above. Like sling bags, sling baby carriers are worn across the shoulder and the baby sits across your body. They can be made of stretchy supportive fabric, but can also be made with rigid materials as seen in backpack carriers.
Sling carriers are generally the most basic styles of carrier designs, and most brands now tend to exclude this design from their product ranges. Still, if you have a newborn and wanting an intimate feeling, a sling carrier may still be the best bet.
Carrying your baby can sometimes be the most convenient option when you’re out and about, but it can also be putting the most strain on your body, particularly if you have to carry your bundle of joy for long periods of time. It’s no surprise that back pain comes with the territory of being a parent, as carrying your child can alter your posture, changing how your body responds to the extra weight, and potentially putting pressure on places that shouldn’t feel pressure.
While your priority may be the comfort of your child, you shouldn’t overlook your own comfort when it comes to choosing a baby carrier or sling. In addition to being comfortable, it should help take the weight off your lower back and shoulders, allowing you to relax muscles and prevent them from straining. Some brands and models offer additional straps, belts and supports to make sure you’re not carrying all of the weight in your lower back, meaning looking at the weight distribution of each model available is a good place to start. Ultimately though, baby carriers and slings are made to help you safely carry the weight of your child, but your own posture and strength will determine whether or not they are the best option for you.
It’s important to take time in finding the right fit for you and your baby. As your baby grows, the heavier it will get and the more back support you may need. Most baby carriers are ‘one size fits most’, being easily adjustable for your bub and allowing for sharing between parents. Plus, if you want to make it a fashion statement, the wide array of designs and fabrics can also come into play. However, it would be wise to keep in mind the price as well as the ergonomics behind it.
This report was written by Canstar Blue’s home & lifestyle journalist, Tahnee-Jae Lopez-Vito. She’s an expert on household appliances, grooming products and all things grocery and shopping. In addition to translating our expert research into consumer-friendly ratings reports, Tahnee spends her time helping consumers make better-informed purchase decisions on all manner of consumer goods and services, while highlighting the best deals and anything you need to be aware of.
Picture credits: Olesia Bilkei/shutterstock.com, Dvorakova Veronika/shutterstock.com, Halfpoint/shutterstock.com, Natalia Deriabina/shutterstock.com, sandsun/shutterstock.com, Trendsetter Images/shutterstock.com, aijiro/shutterstock.com
Our latest customer satisfaction research on baby carriers saw a number of brands rated best in different categories:
Canstar Blue surveyed 1,200 Australian parents of children aged 6 years and under across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have purchased a baby carrier / sling / wrap in the last three years – in this case, 407 people.
Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then by mean overall satisfaction. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.
2019
2018
2017
2016
Baby Car Seat Reviews & Ratings - March 29th
You’d be ‘quackers’ to keep rubber ducks and other plastic toys in the bath, according to new research.
A group of Swiss and US researchers have delved into “the dark side” of rubber ducks and found …
– Read more
Baby Car Seat Reviews & Ratings - March 26th
Dog-lovers are being warned about a new breed of online scammer, tugging on the heartstrings of Australians who want to buy cute puppies.
Scamwatch has reported almost 600 incidents of scams involving puppies in the last …
– Read more
Acne Skincare Reviews - March 19th
The majority of Australians are still in the dark about when they need to start applying sunscreen and protect themselves from harmful UV rays, new research shows.
The Cancer Council Australia’s National Sun Protection survey revealed that …
– Read more
Acne Skincare Reviews - March 12th
Queensland researchers have designed a new online tool that can predict your chances of developing skin cancer over the next three years.
The QIMR Berghofer Medical Research Institute in Brisbane has launched the online test based …
– Read more
Air Conditioner Reviews & Ratings - February 14th
While they’re more commonly used in winter, the air-conditioning can also take its toll on your skin and immune system in summer. Follow our guide to find the right humidifier for you.
– Read more