Butter Ratings


Compare butters from ALDI, Mainland, Lurpak, Western Star, Devondale, Woolworths, Coles and Black & Gold on taste, texture, packaging, ease of spreading, value for money and overall customer satisfaction in 2019.

See Our Ratings Methodology

Most Satisfied Customers | ALDI Beautifully Butterfully

For the fourth year in a row, ALDI Beautifully Butterfully has topped our customer satisfaction ratings for butter. It got five-star reviews for overall satisfaction, texture, value for money and packaging design, as well as four stars for taste and ease of spreading.

ALDI knows how to make things ‘butter’

Butter is the unsung hero of any muffin, croissant, crumpet or morning toast. It’s the staple that pops up in all kinds of recipes, so you’re bound to have it stocked in your fridge ready to be whipped into action. As the backbone to your meals and desserts, butter needs to have the right blend of taste and value, so which brand do Aussie shoppers love most in the dairy aisle?

Canstar Blue surveys thousands of Aussie consumers every year to find out what they think of the groceries they buy, including butter. Brands are rated on a number of factors relating to the type of product, and when it comes to butter, this included factors like taste, texture, packaging and ease of spreading.

This year, close to 2,000 shoppers took part in our butter ratings, and while eight brands received the minimum sample size to be included, only ALDI’s Beautifully Butterfully butter received five stars from consumers for overall satisfaction. It’s the fourth year in a row that ALDI has topped this food category. It also earned five-star reviews on texture, value for money and packaging design, as well as four stars for taste and ease of spreading.

The eight brands in our 2019 butter review were rated in the following order for overall satisfaction:

  • 1st ALDI Beautifully Butterfully Butter
  • 2nd Mainland
  • 3rd Lurpak
  • 4th Western Star
  • 5th Devondale
  • 6th Woolworths
  • 7th Coles
  • 8th Black & Gold

While ALDI took top spot, Mainland, Lurpak, Western Star and Devondale all scored four stars overall. Supermarket brands Woolworths, Coles and Black & Gold (IGA) got only three stars apiece for overall satisfaction. Other results of note include Mainland being the only brand to score five stars for taste and ease of spreading. It also achieved five stars for texture, along with this year’s winner.

What to consider when buying butter

Apart from discovering which butter brands Aussies love most, our research also identified some key findings. One in four survey respondents (26%) said they eat butter every day, making it a staple on the grocery list. A third (31%) primarily use butter for cooking. Additionally, 38% have tried multiple butter brands and types. Here are some of the other key findings from our survey:


As an important ingredient in so many meals – as well as simply the thing we put on toast – taste is naturally a key factor in determining customer satisfaction. If our ratings are anything to go by, there can be a big difference. So, if your butter isn’t providing you with that great taste you’re after, it’s easy to switch.

  • Mainland was the only brand to get five stars for taste in our review, with ALDI, Lurpak, Western Star and Devondale on four stars and the rest on three.


Texture was also found to be an important driver of customer satisfaction when it comes to butter.

  • The two brands rated five stars for texture were ALDI Beautifully Butterfully and Mainland. Lurpak, Western Star and Devondale got four stars apiece, while the rest got three stars.

Value for money

Value for money seems to be an important factor for Aussies, with ALDI scoring top marks in this area, while in some other categories it got four stars. When it comes to price, our survey identified that about one in five consumers (21%) said they always buy the cheapest brand, and almost two in five (36%) always buy the same brand.

  • ALDI Beautifully Butterfully was the only brand to achieve five stars on value for money, with Lurpak on three stars and the rest on four.


While packaging design shouldn’t make any real difference to the butter itself, it could certainly help convince you to try one brand over another. Have you seen the length of the butter aisle – where do you even start? Some brands offer a measuring guide on their packaging, which removes the need to get your scale out when you’re cooking. You might also find some packaging is better than others after it has been opened. There’s nothing worse than butter going bad because the packaging lets you down.

  • This year’s overall winner, ALDI, got five stars for packaging, with the rest securing either three or four stars.

Ease of spreading

Last but certainly not least, having butter that’s easy to spread is a plus. It’s never fun when butter is rock hard and destroys the delicate little piece of toast that you’re trying to spread it on. Some brands boast their products as “spreadable” on the packaging, but only you can be the judge of that.

  • Mainland was the only brand to get five stars on ease of spreading.

So, there you have it! If your butter isn’t buttering you up any more, there’s plenty of choice out there.

Margarine Ratings

Picture credits: stockcreations/shutterstock.com, 4 PM production/shutterstock.com, TY Lim/shutterstock.com

Frequently Asked Questions

Canstar Blue surveyed 3,000 Australian adults across a range of categories to measure and track customer satisfaction, via ISO 26362 accredited research panels managed by Qualtrics. The outcomes reported are the results from customers within the survey group who have purchased and consumed butter from a supermarket or grocer in the last 3 months – in this case, 1,900 people.

Brands must have received at least 30 responses to be included. Results are comparative and it should be noted that brands receiving three stars have still achieved a satisfaction measure of at least six out of 10. Not all brands available in the market have been compared in this survey. The ratings table is first sorted by star ratings and then by mean overall satisfaction. A rated brand may receive a ‘N/A’ (Not Applicable) rating if it does not receive the minimum number of responses for that criteria.

Latest Fridge Food Articles

Coles recalls vegan chocolate due to presence of milk

Supermarket giant Coles has apologised after admitting that some chocolate blocks marketed to vegans actually contained milk. The New South Wales Food Authority issued a statement stating Coles is conducting a national recall of Coles Sugar …

– Read more

New research finds that nuts help reduce risk of heart failure

A handful of nuts might just be what the doctor ordered, according to a new study. Eating nuts regularly could prevent the development of heart failure and an irregular heartbeat. A study conducted by scientists from Sweden, …

– Read more

New study reveals six cups of coffee a day may be healthy

If you’ve been thinking about cutting down on your morning coffees, think again. New research has found drinking up to six cups of coffee a day may be healthy for you. The review of 11 major …

– Read more
ice cream calories

The ice cream that could help you lose weight

Want to eat a whole tub of ice cream without the guilt? A new brand has hit the supermarket shelves and fitness fanatics are going crazy for it. Halo Top ice cream was founded by Los …

– Read more

How to lose weight while still eating pasta

No longer do you need to pass by that delicious bowl of spaghetti or carbonara, with a new study claiming that you can lose weight while still enjoying your favourite pasta dish. Conventional wisdom – and …

– Read more